This recipe is excellent. I'm usually not a big cookie fan. I mixed this for a friend of mine who loves Vurve's Milk and Sugar Cookies.I forgot to throw this recipe in the bag of bottles I gave him. I figured I would give it a taste. I'm really impressed. The balance is spot on perfect. I get this buttery cookie with a vanilla frosting. I did mix it at 15/85. I would mix this up if you don't have Holy Vanilla that the original recipe uses. I need Holy Vanilla in my life also. I bet this recipe is even better with it, but this is going into my rotation without it..Good Job on this one!