DIY SadBoy Butter Cookie Remix ejuice recipe

Delicious right off the shake. It gets even better with 2-3 days. By then I’m usually mixing more. It’s that good. If you are/were a fan of Butter Cookie, then this is it. I promise.

This was my favorite commercial liquid. Before I started mixing, I would look for a clone and when I couldn’t find one, It would scare me away from getting into DIY. Well, I started mixing about a month ago. Been tasting single flavors every day since. When I tested CAP Lemon meringue pie, I knew right away that it was the main ingredient in Butter Cookie. Now all I had to do was figure out the rest.

CAP Lemon meringue pie - I knew right away that this was the main ingredient in SadBoys version. I tried it at 5% and 8% but it wasn’t quite enough. It didn’t have that full airyness that Sadboy does. So I bumped it up to 12% and it is perfect there IMO. I’ve vaped 5,000mls+ of BC so I’m confident in this.

FA Lemon Sicily - I tried TPA Lemon first at 2%. It works but it’s not spot on. I’m sure most lemons would work at a low % to help bring the lemon out of LMP. I settled on FA lemon Sicily because it had the perfect potency at 1.25% and pairs amazingly with LMP. It also doesn’t have that slightly harsh quality of TPA lemon. This helps make the lemon vibrant but not over the top. It also has a sort of shake and vape ability to it that other lemons I’ve tried don’t have. Most need 1-3 days to settle down a bit. This one has been good off the shake for me in multiple recipes.

CAP Sugar Cookie v1 - Probably my favorite concentrate. I believe that this is also a definite flavor in the original. It’s the best Cookie there is IMO and it really helps replicate SadBoys amazing cookie base. It brings a light creaminess and an ever so slight vanilla touch that stays in the background but really helps with the mouthfeel and boosts the sweetness.

TPA Sweetener - Started with this at 2% as I believe most commercial liquids use a minimum of 2% sweetener. I took it down to 1% because I like to run this in an RTA. I used this one because it’s the one I grabbed out of my cupboard. You’d be fine with any sweetener you have. Be sure to adjust % accordingly. This recipe is also still delightful without sweetener. It’s just not spot on to the original. Delicious nonetheless.

I hope you enjoy. Let me know what you think! Going to try to replicate some of SadBoys other flavors as well.

Comments

#1 by ArgenMixer, Mar 26. 2020, 15:55

Delicious !! great recipe , this is the best sad boy cookie clone !! thanks !!!

#2 by Vapetorious, Mar 27. 2020, 20:22

@Ivan thank you! Without trying to sound arrogant, I too think this is the best clone out there for SB BC. I’m glad you like it! I can’t put it down. Love how it’s got the full flavor, basically off the shake! Enjoy my friend!

#3 by CheepShot, Apr 3. 2020, 14:59

Spot on Sadboy clone, thanks!

#4 by DruZod, Apr 29. 2020, 23:33

Spot on, and great Job!

#5 by packgirl04, Jun 2. 2020, 08:03

Tastes just like the original. Delicious!!

#6 by Me8odios, Jul 24. 2020, 09:27

It's very tasty, thank you! Although lemon is gone after a few days and maybe you have to renew it with some drops every now and then...

#7 by jayquik03, Aug 23. 2020, 00:57

Tried this subbed out the sweetener for Cap Super Sweet @5%. Great S&V (which i prefer over steeping). Never tried the original but this is very good.

#8 by Tlk, Sep 24. 2020, 11:13

Do you use lemon meringue pie v1 or v2

#9 by FerretXXXL, Oct 26. 2020, 23:59

I've never tried the original but this is delicious and I havent steeped it at all yet, love how the lemon lingers a little afterward.

#10 by westernkiwi, Nov 11. 2020, 07:21

Tasty. Finally I have a use for cap, Lemon meringue pie.

#11 by Daveflowers9, Dec 19. 2020, 17:12

Damn, this is really very good off the shake, Thank you for sharing!

#12 by B.Neese, Jan 25. 2021, 08:36

I've never had SB Butter Cookie, but Wow! This is the best S&V I've ever had. Have to keep stocked up on these 4 flavors now. Thank you!

#13 by MrBowlingAlley, Apr 6. 2021, 22:14

I also never had the real thing. But I can say this mix is pretty good. Flavor is good even after 24 hours. And yes, I suspect this will taste even better as the days go on. Thanks!

#14 by Mesh3al White , May 24. 2021, 00:06

Hi .. What percent would be good for LMP v2 ? I tried the same percentage here and didn't notice the v2, it was not vapable.

#15 by Lunapigen, Mar 10. 2022, 15:30

Will try it. You got a sadboy custard cookie on the way? :D

#16 by nithint1093, Aug 22. 2024, 18:33

Seeing from the comments who say it's exactly a clone, it taste nothing like even a lemon cookie let alone sadboy butter cookie. It's very one dimensional. As expected, with just 1% sugar cookie and rest all lemon, it taste pretty much like if u make a single flavor out of the CAP lemon meringue pie.

#17 by nithint1093, Aug 25. 2024, 11:06

Edit, added 1% Cap ss and it's much better. From 1 to a 2 in rating