DIY Butter Cookie ejuice recipe :: e-Liquid Calculator

#1 by Maddash, Feb 28. 2016, 18:00

This is a 5 star for sure. This is such a taste juice. This is a winner

#2 by Maddash, Feb 29. 2016, 04:03

I made a 30 ml and blow throw that so I got a 120 steeping now thank u thank u

#3 by avtomat5150, Jun 22. 2016, 16:12

This is absolutely delicious. Thanks for sharing!

#4 by chyde777, Jul 9. 2016, 18:20

Cake batter dip? Any subs on this ? I have Cap cake batter or to different to sub ?

#5 by sammstein, Sep 17. 2016, 06:08

Just mixed some of this up...smells fucking delicious!!!

#6 by Zugmaschine, Sep 28. 2016, 16:09

@Jaykay1, @all - Cake batter dip? Any subs on this ? I have Cap cake batter or is that to different to sub ?

#7 by Fleming, Nov 3. 2016, 23:11

I did cake batter cap and marshmallow fa and its amazing best juice ive had

#8 by benjy337, Dec 5. 2016, 16:13

Very good as a SNV, I'm sure it will be excellent after a steep.
I used Cake Batter (CAP), and (TPA) sweetener instead of Ethyl Malthol .

#9 by Zugmaschine, Dec 11. 2016, 19:59

Marsmallow from CAP, is the sweetest but have not so authentic Marsmallow-Smell! Marsmallow from FA is most authentic but not so sweet like the CAP one! Marsmallow from FWis in the mddle!
Nice Recipe! Thanks.

#10 by FunnySlumberBunny, Mar 11. 2017, 17:32

What is the difference in Cake Batter Dip and Caps Cake Batter?

#11 by TheVgGuy, Aug 21. 2017, 13:25

what if i dont have cake batter

#12 by APOSTOLOS, Sep 7. 2017, 16:15

if i have not nic 72mg 100% vg but i have 20 mg 100% vg what i can do ? i am from greece and the shops have onle 18 - 20 mg.

#13 by Myrkva, Sep 10. 2017, 23:56

apostolos you just adapt the recipe (tool icon) and change your value to 20mg vg nicotine vg. you will need more of nicotine that than actual plain vg base, but still easy to do :) then just save it as a private recipe for you to mix

#14 by APOSTOLOS, Sep 11. 2017, 10:29

THNX A LOT!! i think that recipe needs more than 3 days!!!!!

#15 by Recipemaking101, Oct 3. 2017, 19:22

FIRST mixing session ever completed 2 days ago and this was one of five recipes I did and the only one I've tasted so far as it stated a 2-3 day steep. As I was out of my purchased juices I only waited 1.5 days before having some of this. OF COURSE, being a newbie, I didn't have all the flavors--I was missing the SUGAR COOKIE and didn't worry about any of my flavors being from different manufacturers, but as your cotton candy was different and said 10% EM and I had no clue if my Flavor West was the same, I also made adjustments for that.

My effort to MIMIC (just get in the same ball park) the sugar cookie ingredient I was missing included using Vanilla Swirl and Butter Cream in its place along with using extra Graham, Marshmallow, and Cotton Candy, those extra flavors and extra amounts of your existing flavors were made to EQUAL the amount of Sugar Cookie you used and, OMG, I can't believe out of the gate first time the vape I mixed turned out so good and can't imagine how yummy it will be in a few more days! I wish I'd mixed up more than the 15 ML I mixed! (but not having an ingredient and being new, I was worried)

I can't wait to buy some sugar cookie and do it again exactly as your recipe called for! This site along with youtube videos has been incredible for me and I want to thank you and everyone else for contributing! I don't know how this works, if you can see my rating, but if not, I gave you five stars! Thank you.

#16 by Recipemaking101, Oct 3. 2017, 19:23

PS I've always purchased juice at 50/50 pg/vg with 6-12% nic and that is how I did this recipe--was great!

#17 by Brett, Nov 15. 2017, 08:24

Followed the recipe exactly. Steeped for 4 weeks. Tried RDA and Tank at different settings over period of 1 week. Very weak flavor.

#18 by Eyebrowse, May 7. 2018, 16:59

I did somewhat of a remake of your flavour (I felt to call it just a 'tweak' was a bit of a stretch IMO), after the first time where I just swapped out the Cake Batter Dip > CAP cake Batter and TPA Marshmallow out of necessity (missing flavours) - definitely impressed - but then went a few steps further with a second variation:

I dropped the Vanilla Custard cos I felt the CAP Cake Batter already filled sorta the same role, in favour of 2% TPA Meringue and 1% FW Hazelnut.
Added 0.5% CAP Graham Cracker V2 and 1% Sugar Cookie (Real Flavours) too.
Oh and an additional 0.5% of Acetyl Pyrazine just to help finish it all off.

It's a fair step away from your own recipe - some might say maybe a little too complex too - but it definitely tastes and smells promising straight away. Just gonna give it a couple days to steep as with the original too see how well it fairs before I make more. But even if nothing else, I think at least a drop of AP is definitely helpful either way.

#19 by Eyebrowse, Jul 2. 2018, 22:38

Update: Now I've got FW Cake Batter Dip I'm deffo gonna give this a go at trying to keep to the original recipe (my intentions at least, but I usually end up mixing while drunk and impulsively throwing in whatever my flavour of the moment is and straying way off the weights - from time to time this has led to some mindblowing creations - as well as a handful of rejects - but I also have a habit of forgetting to actually save or write down such 'Eureka!' moments much to my frustration...)

#20 by Animgiant, Apr 7. 2019, 19:56

damm fukin super good

#21 by Rob, Apr 7. 2021, 12:37

Similar experience to Brett above; It's not a bad flavour as such, it's just weak.

Seems to suffer the classic "it's just generic sweet air" curse that so many others do. No real hook to it, no signature taste that makes me want another tank of it.

#22 by Rob, Apr 7. 2021, 12:57

If you like the place this recipe seems to be trying to go with the Sugar Cookie and Vanilla Custard, I'd recommend giving this one a shot:

e-liquid-recipes.com/recipe/1010597/Cannoli%20Contest%20Entry%20DIYorDIE

Not a million miles away in overall theme, but MUCH punchier and a lot more interest between the flavours.