DIY Butter cookies ejuice recipe :: e-Liquid Calculator

#1 by cloudwatcher81, May 23. 2016, 19:33

I have been on the hunt for a really good baked flavor for over a month...this is by far the best I have had yet, Thank you so much for sharing this recipe...you rock.

#2 by MassiveCloudz, May 23. 2016, 23:50

Can i up butter cream and sub it for golden butter.I don't have any golden butter

#3 by Kopel, May 24. 2016, 00:55

You could probably just exclude the golden butter. I don't think upping the butter cream would make up the difference. It will be different, but still pretty good.

#4 by KittyVapes, Jun 6. 2016, 18:38

HocusKrocus do you think it will change the flavor much if I use TFA Sweet Cream and sucralose instead of the CAPS version?

#5 by Kopel, Jun 6. 2016, 19:48

I would use 1% Sucralose since CAP is a fair bit stronger. Tfa sweet creamshould be fine, though couldn't say for sure.

#6 by KittyVapes, Jun 7. 2016, 03:37

Thanks. I will let you know how this is after steeping.

#7 by SamKayla, Jun 26. 2016, 03:24

How long of a steep does this need?! And that's tfa sucralose right ?

#8 by Kopel, Jun 26. 2016, 20:54

Yes, TFA Sucralose. It's pretty good fresh surprisingly, but I liked it best after 6-7 days

#9 by SamKayla, Jun 28. 2016, 17:17

Ok ! Cool thanks ! And thanks for sharing this recipe !! I love butter cookies , and also are they suspose to the like the Danish butter cookies in the blue can that come out around Christmas time !?

#10 by Kopel, Jun 29. 2016, 01:31

Exactly! I called them sewing kit cookies as a kid, since that's what my mom kept all her sewing stuff in.

#11 by SamKayla, Jun 29. 2016, 02:08

Oh ok Cool ! Man thanks again I can't wait to try this recipe !! those cookies are awesome !!

#12 by KittyVapes, Jul 6. 2016, 22:24

HocusKrokus, I just finished my original bottle of this juice today and will be making another larger batch. Thank you again for this recipe! Oh and I wanted you to know that I also mixed some with shisha strawberry and it made an extremely flavorful vape.

#13 by Kopel, Jul 7. 2016, 03:07

Glad you liked it! Thanks for the kind words. You can really add almost anything, using this cookie as a base since it's pretty neutral. I like to add FW Hazelnut and FA Almond when I make this sometimes :)

#14 by KittyVapes, Jul 7. 2016, 03:44

I tend to be a flavor junkie and can't believe I smoked the same brand cigs for years! I have mods and tanks all over my house where there used to be ashtrays. I have to have several flavors daily and this one is so versatile.

#15 by Briz1973, Aug 11. 2016, 05:30

I'm planning on mixing a few of your recipes, this one in particular. I normally mix around 17-24%. I've always preferred in your face flavor. What do you think the result would be, if I doubled your recipe here? Do you think anything would be too high, percent wise, as to mute parts of the recipe? Just wondering.... This does look nicely balanced, even before mixing. I can usually tell... Thanks!

#16 by Kopel, Aug 11. 2016, 06:56

I think that doubling it would have an end result of simply being overflavored, and likely cause some muting or some balance issues as the butter and butter cream would likely take over. If you're open to it, why not try it the way I've written it, then if you feel it's a bit low for you, increase the sugar cookie 1-2% and the rest by only a small amount. Though I think you'll find the original is plenty flavorful.

#17 by GeneO, Aug 22. 2016, 21:00

Just got around to trying the batch I made a couple weeks ago. Man this is so awesome. Dead on the butter cookies my grandma used to get when I was a kid.

#18 by Hutchy, Aug 22. 2016, 21:55

I am going to try this but with no sucralose, do you think it would be a good idea to add joy or biscuit at a low percentage or no?

#19 by Kopel, Aug 22. 2016, 22:30

I tried variations with both, and they just didn't fit here. Joy starts pushing it into cakey territory, and biscuit was too much added butteryness. I mix it fairly often for myself without sucralose. It won't be the same, but it will still be pretty good.

#20 by Hutchy, Aug 23. 2016, 04:51

thanks brother

#21 by norwegianvaper, Sep 1. 2016, 21:21

Looks good. Some say that Ethyl Malthol /sucralose (same thing?) tend to mute flavors over time. If so, would it be an idea to blend those in after stepping and add it just to the bottle you are about to use? That is a general question for all recipes who have EM in it.

#22 by Kopel, Sep 1. 2016, 21:25

EM and sucralose are not at all the same. EM does mute recipes over time, but I don't find the same to be true of sucralose. Generally, it's fine to add your EM around 12-24 hours prior to using a juice to get a decent effect. But they are definitely not the same. Sucralose should steep with your flavors, so it's better to add it right away.

#23 by ViTALiTY, Sep 16. 2016, 17:14

I used FW Butter Cream instead, same percentage. Smells really good.

#24 by Katumbas, Oct 22. 2016, 19:19

Kopel, what % do you use on FW Hazelnut and FA Almond to the recipe?
Thank you :)

#25 by Kopel, Oct 22. 2016, 19:26

2-3% FW Hazelnut and around .5-1% FA Almond

#26 by Katumbas, Oct 23. 2016, 00:59

Gonna give a try! Thank you :)

#27 by WhiteRaven, Oct 29. 2016, 23:06

Great recipe! Thanks!

#28 by diyjuicer, Nov 7. 2016, 05:53

I did 30ml and finished it before steeping a full week. Did that twice. So I made 60ml, waited a week before I started into it. That lasted about 2 weeks (3 weeks total steep), and the taste was the best yet! Time for a 120ml batch! Thanks Mr. K!

#29 by Kopel, Nov 7. 2016, 16:08

Glad you enjoyed it that much sir!

#30 by Mich86, Nov 24. 2016, 17:51

love it , bought the concentrate from chefs well done :)

#31 by RudeRudi, Dec 11. 2016, 20:50

I can't get CAP sugar cookie V1 in my country - only V2...I have V2 but sure it will work in here? Any other sub?

#32 by RudeRudi, Dec 11. 2016, 20:50

I can't get CAP sugar cookie V1 in my country - only V2...I have V2 but sure it will work in here? Any other sub?

#33 by Kopel, Dec 11. 2016, 21:10

The v2 will likely work just fine, maybe just need a bit longer of a steep

#34 by RudeRudi, Dec 12. 2016, 05:00

Perfect, thanks!

#35 by Jayrell, Feb 2. 2017, 05:38

I'm gonna make this it looks awesome! I only have TFA sweet cream though is it a suitable replacement?

#36 by Kopel, Feb 2. 2017, 07:13

It should be okay, though I can't be certain because I don't have any on hand and have never used it.

#37 by Jayrell, Feb 2. 2017, 07:27

I will let you know how it comes out

#38 by diliaki, Apr 3. 2017, 23:32

I did this recipe on 16 March with a little bit of inawera's biscuit as I think it would be suitable and indeed it is awesome! Thank you Kopel for sharing!

#39 by ShawnTheOne, May 1. 2017, 10:45

Kopel would FW Sugar Cookie work in this?

#40 by Kopel, May 1. 2017, 12:01

It would definitely not be he same, but it would probably be pretty good.

#41 by ShawnTheOne, May 1. 2017, 20:27

I'll give it a shot and if not I guess I will be placing another concentrate order. Lol

#42 by Zugmaschine, Jul 16. 2017, 12:55

Hi Kopel.
Can i use Super Sweet (CAP) as Sweetener?

#43 by Kopel, Jul 16. 2017, 16:52

Yes, but use half as much

#44 by Zugmaschine, Jul 16. 2017, 20:57

Thanks Kopel Do u know Super Sweet? Have u ever use it? I have the feeling that it have a special smell, a little like acid.

#45 by Kopel, Jul 17. 2017, 09:38

It does contain citric acid

#46 by Zugmaschine, Jul 17. 2017, 12:20

So that means Super Sweet is not to us on every Recipe?
On Fruits only?

#47 by Kopel, Jul 18. 2017, 03:32

No, it's just a component of Super Sweet. You can use it in most places that you would use sweetener if that's what you like. It can help some flavors stand out better, and it's a pretty low amount so it shouldn't negatively affect other types of flavors.

#48 by damian, Aug 28. 2017, 15:32

I made this recipe and i left it to steep for one month and it is delicious.I want your opinion on whether i should put cinamon danish swirl at 0.5% or not.

#49 by LBabcock, Sep 25. 2017, 05:54

This is amazing!!!! Great Job

#50 by Kopel, Sep 25. 2017, 07:06

@Damian sorry for the late reply, but yes you could add .5% CAP CDS if you're into cinnamon cookies. @Laura, thanks again! So glad you and yours liked it!

#51 by OldGuyVaper (OGV), Oct 4. 2017, 19:58

Great recipe, Kopel! I mixed up my 2nd batch last night, and gonna do a 3rd now, with the changes you suggested to Briz1973, way back near the top of the comments -- I'd like a stronger Cookie taste...

#52 by Zugmaschine, Oct 21. 2017, 21:31

Thanks for that nice Recipe Kopel. When u want make a Hazelnut-Cookie, how much FW Hazelnut u Use? And you make it directly to the mix, or first after some time steeping?

#53 by Kopel, Oct 21. 2017, 22:39

I'd probably look at around 2% FW Hazelnut. I'd add it right when I first mix so that it can steep alongside everything else.

#54 by weeva, Dec 30. 2017, 20:00

can i change Golden Butter (CAP) to TFA Butter and maintain the same taste ? if yes what percentage for tfa butter do you recommend ?

#55 by Kopel, Jan 3. 2018, 14:44

I haven't tried it in this recipe, but they are pretty close so it shouldn't be really different.

#56 by Alepp, Jan 17. 2018, 04:08

Can i change sweet cream (cap) to sweet cream (tpa) ?

#57 by Kopel, Jan 17. 2018, 04:50

I've never tried it with TPA Sweet Cream but it work in theory

#58 by Robin, Jan 31. 2018, 19:10

Mmmmm.. Butter... and cookies! Awesome! Loved it after only 3 days. Gonna put it away for another week to see what happens.

#59 by TwoTone, Feb 27. 2018, 13:46

Fantastic recipe. Going to use Hazelnut FW and a drop of Acetyl Pirazine to give it some more GO!! lol..

#60 by TiroMuerto, Jun 1. 2018, 10:41

Steeping days ??

#61 by Kopel, Jun 1. 2018, 16:46

10-14 days

#62 by Rik King, Jun 30. 2018, 05:43

So rich!

#63 by Mgunit13, Jul 18. 2018, 19:19

@Kopel... thanks for this recipe, it looks great...going to mix this up within next month and come back to rate.
And lol at ur comment about your mom using the blue cookie tin for sewing stuff, my mom did they same thing lol... I would open the butter cookie blue tin, looking forward to a cookie but I got needles instead, lmao

@everyone, just a suggestion to always read the notes and always read all the comments, because I see the same questions asked over and over and if you just read the comments ur questions would be answered..lol.... not just that but you can learn alot too ;)

#64 by ZIAD TORKEY , Aug 2. 2018, 00:48

I'm so interested in trying your recipe, but i don't have ( Butter Cream (CAP), Golden Butter (CAP) or Sweet Cream (CAP) ).
But I have ( Butter (TPA), Bavarian Cream (TPA), Sweet Cream (TPA), Vanilla Bean Ice Cream (TPA), Vanilla Custard (TPA) and Vanilla Swirl (TPA))
Can you guide me how to reach the same taste with what I have?
and how to make it sweet like commercial ejuice with Sweetener (Sucralose/Maltol) (TPA) ?

Thanks for your help in advance :)

#65 by BigDad, Sep 22. 2018, 10:30

Just made another litre of this, over 2 years on from the posting date and still my all time favourite all day vape eliquid, through countless atomizers and tanks it delivers each time every time, you should be proud Chris, I know I would be!

#66 by VapePrix, Nov 28. 2018, 23:27

Tasted it, loved it and finally adapt it. One of the best vlavors ever for a sweet guy like me :D 5*****

#67 by Dio, Nov 30. 2018, 20:25

The best cookie juice ever!!!! Great job buddy thanks alot 5starzz

#68 by Nosvape, Feb 15. 2019, 12:51

Great mix, one of the best featuring CAP Sugar Cookie.

#69 by luuul, Jul 4. 2019, 16:30

Can I up the percentage.of golden butter to make it more buttery?

#70 by Kopel, Jul 4. 2019, 16:33

You can. But after .5ish it gets really oveewhelming and kinda greasy

#71 by luuul, Jul 4. 2019, 16:34

alright ill try .5 thanks i love bhtter mhh

#72 by Basil.Blanc, Jul 20. 2019, 11:29

I get a nice fluffy buttery kind of cookie taste, cookie is not too strong. Tastes a lot like the old fashioned cookies it's supposed to emulate. Couldn't resist the urge and added blueberry, it's lovely! Thank you for sharing Kopel.

#73 by RedHouseMixer, Feb 28. 2020, 19:56

Thanks!

#74 by Confused, Apr 16. 2020, 22:19

Basil.Blanc what blueberry did you use and at what %.

#75 by Martin777, Jul 7. 2020, 11:36

It's very good after 1-2 weeks steeping. Make small amount! I made 300ml and the taste change after long steep. Now I'm trying to fix it with no luck :(

#76 by Emin0, Jul 14. 2020, 18:17

Im gonna mix this up it seems to be realy nice with all the comments=)

#77 by DanielTheVapeMan, Dec 7. 2020, 02:14

Amazing mix and all you do is add your favorite fruit and boom. Classic

#78 by DanielTheVapeMan, Dec 12. 2020, 21:57

5⭐

#79 by A Boy and his Blotto, Jan 11. 2021, 13:18

I kinda made the same recipe. Van Custard Cap v1 6,5% - Cap Butter cream 4.5% - Sugar Cookie v1 7% - and 1% of Cotton Candy EM.

Total is 19% flavorings, in a 80+VG mix. Is that way too much flavorings? See this popular one hasnt even got 10% total

#80 by Kopel, Jan 11. 2021, 16:13

I find butter cream to be a really potent flavoring, even with the other ingredients that high I think our recipes would taste quite different.

But taste is subjective so if it's not too much for you then that's just fine

#81 by A Boy and his Blotto, Jan 11. 2021, 16:18

How can I tell when it is too much? What happens when you put too much flavorings inside, does that supress the flavour? Im not that experienced. Tested it today and the taste isnt that full and strong. It has steeped for 4 days now.

#82 by Kopel, Jan 11. 2021, 20:40

Overflavoring can DEFINITELY lead to muting especially in the case of really heavy creams and dessert type flavors. Best practice is to start low and work your way up. The original versions of this recipe started at around 5-6% total and worked their way up.

It also depends on what kind of hardware you're using to vape your testers in! Lots of variables. It will take time to learn the best ways to hit your personal thresholds for an optimal vape.

#83 by mitsos, Jan 23. 2021, 11:54

just perfect !!!
and I admire you for the support (even after 5 years)
5 *****

#84 by D.Sims, Jan 28. 2023, 03:12

Awesome stuff dude!! Many, MANY THANKS!! 🙏🙏